Portfolio360
Portfolio360
Know Where You Stand, Financially
Personal Finance

Why I'm Shutting Down Our Circle Community

What Four Years of Experiments Taught Me About Community

Khizar Kahloon | May 1, 2026

Community

Some of you have been with me for years. Some joined recently. No matter when you joined, thank you for being part of this journey. I want to share where we have been, what I have learned, and where we are going next.

Saturday Nights on Twitter Spaces

It started on Twitter Spaces in 2022, on Saturday nights. I would invite a market expert, ask them questions for the first half hour, then open the floor to the audience. The conversations were about Pakistan's capital markets, the macros, the economy, sectors, listed companies, and stocks. The country was facing default risk. The market was deeply bearish. Retail investors were starved of honest, unbiased analysis. The Spaces became a weekly gathering where quality discussion was free and accessible to anyone who showed up, and to anyone who tuned in to the recordings later.

What made those nights special was not the speakers alone. It was the audience. Ordinary people asking CEO-level questions. Students, salaried professionals, doctors, traders, retirees, all in one room on a Saturday night, listening, learning, and speaking up. I never missed a week. Fifty weeks in a row. After the golden jubilee episode, I stopped for a break.

The Kahloon Podcast

But the messages kept coming. People wanted me to continue. They said quality content on Pakistan's markets was hard to find in those times, and the mission of financial literacy for the retail investor needed to keep going. So later in 2023, I started The Kahloon Podcast on YouTube.

For nearly a year and a half, without missing a single weekly episode, I sat down with CEOs, CIOs, research analysts, and a few guests focused on careers and personal growth. The response was generous. People wrote in. People watched. Episodes were shared, clipped, debated. The podcast reached corners I could not have reached on Twitter alone.

Early in 2025, I paused. Not because the audience was small, but because I felt something was missing. YouTube was a one-way street. I was talking. People were listening. But the conversation that made the Saturday Spaces special, the back and forth, the questions from the audience, the sense of a room full of curious people learning together, that was missing.

Building a Room on Circle

So I tried something new. I built a community on Circle; The Kahloon Circle. Saturday night casual lives. Sunday night sessions with guests. Group chats. Blog posts. Weekly events. Everything I thought a community should have.

It didn't work the way I hoped. Participation stayed low. Sunday nights felt quiet. So did Saturdays. I told myself people were busy on weekends. I told myself they preferred watching YouTube on their own time. I kept the lights on, kept posting, kept showing up. But I had to be honest with myself. The community wasn't growing into what I imagined.

A Different Kind of Mission

Around the same time, I inaugurated Iqbal Memorial Health Centre in Toba Tek Singh, Pakistan, in memory of my late father. I threw myself into building an in-house Hospital Information Management System to make the centre fully digital and paperless. We built it in record time and launched it. Alongside that, as part of the MentoringForCause initiative, I kept accepting one-on-one sessions from hundreds of fellow Pakistanis around the world who needed personal guidance on their careers and their investing journeys.

Where the Conversation Was Already Happening

In the middle of 2025, I kick-started the work on Portfolio360, a free, multi-country, multi-market, multi-asset, multi-currency net worth tracker for investors who want their complete financial picture in one place. We launched the beta in March 2026. As I poured my time into it, something interesting happened. The same people who were quiet on Circle started writing inside Portfolio360. They reported bugs. They suggested features. They left feedback. They asked questions in the chat module. The conversation I had been chasing on Circle was happening, naturally, inside the product itself.

Bringing the Community Home

So this week, I added a Community section right inside Portfolio360. Updates, Reviews, Events, Live Chat, Report Bugs, Suggest Features, Contribute, all of it now lives in one place, alongside the tool people are already using every day.

This is where the journey leads. I am shutting down our Circle community and bringing everything home to Portfolio360. The hundred dollars a month that Circle costs me will instead go into adding more free features for you. That feels right.

What I Learned

Here is what I have learned across these experiments. A community does not exist because you build the room. It exists because people have a reason to walk in. On Twitter Spaces, the reason was urgency. On YouTube, the reason was the guests and questions I would ask. On Circle, I built a beautiful room and waited for people to come. They did not, because I had not given them a reason yet. Inside Portfolio360, the reason is already there. People come for the tool. The community grows around it.

I am never afraid of experiments that do not work. Spaces taught me about live conversation. The podcast taught me about asking questions. Circle taught me that platforms do not create communities, problems do. Each step was necessary to get to the next one.

Thank You

To those of you who showed up on those Saturday nights in 2022/23, you are the reason any of this exists. To those who joined through the podcast in 2024/25, who watched, shared, and kept asking for more, you kept the mission alive when I needed it most. To everyone who joined Circle, posted in the chats, attended a Sunday session, sent me a message, or just lurked quietly, thank you. None of it was wasted.

The mission has not changed. Financial literacy for the retail investor. Honest, unbiased content. A place where people can learn together. The room is just in a different building now, and the door is open.

See you inside the Community.

Khizar

Open on Portfolio360